Bakery Plus is a trusted bakery and cake shop in Middletown, NY, where fresh ingredients, careful preparation, and a true passion for baking come together in every loaf, pastry, and custom cake.
This is more than a place to satisfy a sweet tooth—it is a welcoming neighborhood destination where customers can rely on consistent quality, thoughtful service, and baked goods made with real care.
With a warm atmosphere and a strong reputation reflected in its 4.60-star rating from 312 reviews, Bakery Plus has earned the confidence of local customers who appreciate both excellent flavor and a dependable, friendly experience.
Whether you are celebrating a once-in-a-lifetime event or simply want something fresh to brighten an ordinary day, Bakery Plus delivers the craftsmanship that makes every bite memorable. Its custom cakes are a standout choice for birthdays, weddings, and other special occasions, offering a polished and personal touch that helps important moments feel even more meaningful.
Alongside those celebration pieces, the bakery also offers fresh daily treats that are perfect for a quick breakfast, an afternoon indulgence, or a thoughtful dessert to share. Every item is prepared to bring the comfort of homemade baking together with the quality and consistency customers expect from a top local bakery and cake shop.
Convenience is built into the experience as well. Bakery Plus offers on-site services, takeaway, and delivery, making it easy to enjoy favorite treats in the way that works best for you.
The shop is designed with accessibility in mind, including a wheelchair-accessible car park and wheelchair-accessible entrance, so more customers can visit with ease and confidence. Payment is simple and flexible too, with credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments accepted.
Located at 383 NY-211, Middletown, NY 10940, United States, and reachable at +1 845-344-2529, Bakery Plus combines great taste, everyday convenience, and genuine hospitality in one inviting place that keeps customers coming back.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Bakery Plus
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
Hear from our valued guests
I'm not a big cake eater, but when I do, this is where it's from! Bakery Plus has the best cake around! The chocolate mousse with raspberry filling or fresh strawberry are my favorites! She uses fresh whipped cream so it’s not too sweet and the cake is always soft and moist.
The cakes, cupcakes, cookies I mean you name it they make it and make it incredibly delicious and decadent! Their chocolate mouse is like eating a chocolate cloud! I ordered most recently a red velvet cake for my sisters birthday and it was done fresh and decorated nicely. They are so easy to work with! They are also very thoughtful because I ordered a cake for someone and they realized some already bought a cake for that same person and she let me know right away that she thinks we might have double cakes. And we did lol but that just shows how much everyone loves them!
Cakes from bakery plus will have your party guests going back for more. There’s usually leftover cake at a party but not with a bakery plus cake. They are beautiful and DELICIOUS! When you pick it up you’re going to buy some more stuff from the bakery case. Dangerously good.
A coworker brought me here last week. There was so much to choose from. I ended up getting 6 slices 2 Boston’s creme, 2 Oreo, one Cannoli, and one chocolate d decadent. Cake was moist. The frosting wasn’t overly sweet. Definitely the best cake slices ever! Definitely coming back to order some cakes! One slice is missing from the box, I had already eaten it before going back to the car.
My coworkers got me a cake for my birthday and it was phenomenal. The cannoli cake is so creamy and moist-nothing about it is dry. The whipped icing is so smooth and compliments the rest of the cake deliciously. I find most bakery’s in the area have an icing that’s so sweet, it’s almost like chalk. Shout out to my colleague, Matt, for the wonderful cake and hooking me on this place. I will definitely go for cakes for personal events!!
I have fallen in love with this bakery. I needed a birthday cheesecake for my bf and he sent me here. He had 3 top picks.. 1. Mango cheesecake, 2. raspberry cheesecake and 3. Strawberry shortcake (in that order) I'm going to be honest I like cheesecake but my favorite is strawberry shortcake. And I thought he was crazy for his order of favorites... until I went in. First of all, they were really diligent about social distancing which I greatly appreciate. 2 guests allowed inside at a time with mandatory masks. Thank you for caring about your customers and keeping us safe. Second of all.. walking in this bakery was like the heavens opening up and sun shining in the room. The cases full of every cookie, cake, cheesecake you can imagine... I literally wanted to buy EVERYTHING. I had a nice chat with the very friendly owner/person behind the counter. She was super nice and helpful to me. As far as my order.... the mango cheesecake only came in a mini cake size, the raspberry cheesecake came in a 7" size so I went with that..and yes.. I HAD to get 2 slices of strawberry shortcake for myself too. The strawberry shortcake was very light and has fresh strawberry throughout the layers... but the star of the day was that raspberry cheesecake.. OMG! Never thought I would say anything was better than shortcake but this raspberry cheesecake was the truth!!! I will be back soon as I find a reason to have another chest day lol.
Very nice pasties and cakes, fresh and the lady is just so sweet. We should promote such small business by helping them to survive in these difficult times.
Stopped in after shopping in Middletown needed to get birthday cake slices for my little sisters birthday the woman helping us was very patient allowing my special needs sisters to study all the slices of cakes before making her decision. The cake was good and The service top notch as well.
I bought an old fashion ice cream cake and a few other brownies and goodies. Everything was delicious and the customer service was wonderful.
I received a surprise cake gift from my client, the cake was soft, moist, and not too sweet. The strawberries were fresh and tangy, and every bite was just perfect. It’s one of the most thoughtful gifts I’ve ever received. Honestly, the best cake in Middletown! The shop is small and cozy, with lots of cute mini cakes. I really want to try their sweet éclairs next time. Everything looked so good!
Common questions about Bakery Plus
Bakery Plus is located at 383 NY-211, Middletown, NY 10940, United States, Middletown, NY, United States.
You can reach Bakery Plus by calling +1 845-344-2529.
Bakery Plus has a rating of 4.6 out of 5 based on 312 customer reviews.
Bakery Plus features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance.
Bakery Plus features the following service options: On-site services, Takeaway, Delivery.
Bakery Plus features the following planning: Quick visit.
Bakery Plus features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Bakery Plus features the following parking: Free parking lot.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
